I have had excellent results with the Polywad shell in all gauges. The people are most pleasant to deal with as well. Same with RST. You are well served with either-- or both.

I want to thank everyone for their imput on this subject, I can say for sure that I will no longer worry about chamber length and using 2 3/4" shells in one of my fine old doubles. It seems now my only choice is whether to order from RST or Polywad, I'm sure they are both excellent choices but I'm leaning toward RST because they support PGCA.

While I appreciate the 'support the PGCA' view, might I suggest it's a tad shortsighted?

First, (I don't know) does RST really support the PGCA or does it just show up to sell its wares? There's a difference.

Second, isn't it fair to say ANY company that bothers to offer a specialty product into a niche market (assuming their product offering is viable) deserves some sort of support from its customer base?

Maybe we could all team up and really go after those SOB's at Polywad. Just who do they think they are? We'll vote with our dollars, that's what we'll do. Then, if they are still around we'll track them down one by one until there is no more Polywad. The nerve!

1st- no one attacked or said anything negative about polywad. The only criticism at all was the inverse in that no one has documented polywad either coming to shoots or being a sponsor.
2nd- Jeff didn't hem and haw when he said "Morris from RST has been a very generous sponsor for PGCA for years." That sounds like support.
3rd- He asked people for their opinions and such are being provided.
4th-Have you considered a career in politics Fish? This level of reactionism defensiveness should play well in the political sphere at this time :) :bowdown:

PS: The last comment is meant purely in jest.

Even though that was meant 'tongue-in-cheek', it's just overreacting.

And that's my personal opinion.

Yes, they show up at most every event I've been to, and sell their wares. They are, in fact the only supplier who bothers to do so, and for that we are all grateful, as many come without ammo, and don't reload.
Additionally, they give generously, many cases of ammo each year for the Silent Auction, at the Annual Meeting, in addition to ammo in the 'Goodie Bags'. If I've been able to observe this much support, it seems logical that there's a darn sight more I don't see. As the First Mate on the tug I worked on used to say "Do you really need Nine Rays of Sunshine blown up your Touch Hole Before you see what everyone else does?" Kinda sums it up in my mind, but maybe not everyone talks like we did, lugging a few million pounds of ordinance.

My comment about attacking Polywad is obviously made tongue-in-cheek...the point simply being that I suspect they are a good company which does not deserve to get a 'thumbs down' just because they don't show up at Parker events. I apologize to those who are unable to comprehend my intention. That's what a tongue-in-cheek comment is - intentional overreaction to help illustrate a point.

Greg, I have been a customer of Poly-Wad for years and Jay Menefee the owner has been nothing short of wonderful with giving information. But I suspect they are a one or two man show so I think doing the traveling thing is out of the question.

Granted Fish, but again no one was attacking polywad. People were simply stating they did business with RST because they like how they support PGCA, not because polywad is a bad company.

i had the last of my polywads in the same pocket as some RSTs weekend before last

no trouble - they got along just fine