JAMES JULIA'S MARCH 2012 AUCTION

[Dean Romig]

In My Humble Opinion I think if anyone else has something to say to Mr. Julia It should be done by PM or personal email. He has provided us with more than enough information on how he conducts his business... even more than we have asked for. I believe he has answered our questions to the best of his abilities without getting into the minute details of each transaction that a few of us might wish to discuss with him in private without "airing the dirty laundry" of some less than satisfied people here. It would do a disservice to all involved to delve any deeper into particular issues one might have with a certain transaction. I think we all have a pretty good idea of the feelings and opinions of some of the participants of this thread But I think any further discussion with Mr. Julia or with each other on this issue should be done off-line - as I said, PM or personal email... otherwise we're and at risk of having this thread blocked and I think there is too much good information here than to have it disappear.

P.S. I have not contacted Mr. Julia about my concerns and may not... "water over the dam" at this point with me.

[MarketHunter]

If he was straight as an arrow he'd have given Eric back his $750 buyers premium. That's the amount of money we're talking about. Should be a drop in the bucket to a person like our Mr. Julia. He must really be hurting for cash, if he's let this all go this far......


DLH

[Bill Murphy]

Amarillo Mike has one of the most pertinent points on this thread, except that he is not up to date on perfectly acceptable wall thickness gauges. You can have a Manson gauge from Brownells for about half what Mike states. By the time most collectors amass a half million dollar shotgun collection, they have had a hundred dollar Manson gauge for many years. Just my inner soft spot talking.

[MarketHunter]

Bill,

Did you read what I had to say? When you buy from somebody like Julia, there shouldn't be mistakes like this. If you buy a gun from them and ask for wall thickness what they tell you should be the gospel. Do you disagree?


DLH

[Opening Day]

Bill, I have a wall thickness gauge now, bought it in June of that year (end of March was the auction) that's how I found out about the problem. Like Destry say's I believed them, my mistake, now I have the gauge, just a little late....

[Bill Murphy]

Destry, sorry, these guys have no idea what they are selling and don't want to know. You have to be the inspector. A good time to do that is the day you open the box. This is no disrespect to the auction houses to say that they have no idea what they are sell, but "They have no idea what they are selling."

[Dean Romig]

PM sent Chris.

[Big Friend Ten (BFT)]

"They have no idea what they are selling."

Murphy,

I think you are correct but the perception is that Julia's is one of the premier gun auctions in this country if not the world! Buying a Parker from Julia's would be as if I were buying it from you. If you told me that the gun has MBWT of .0xx" I'd expect it to be true based on your reputation as a Parker expert. Please accept this as a compliment to your Parker expertise.

There are of course other persons and companies that I would not trust to provide accurate information. Nor would I ever lower myself to buy anything from them. Why should I contribute to their vacations?

This thread is enlightening because at least three respected members of our Parker community have questioned the business dealings of this auction house based on their negative experiances. Although legally the auction house did nothing wrong, my perception of this business entity has been lowered substantially.

I have reached the point in my gun collecting that I am ready to accumulate 5-figure firearms. Three seperate strikes against persons whom I respect indicates that I should look elsewhere.

Perhaps an in-depth investigative artical on "Understanding Gun Auctions" is called for.

"non melior amicus, non nequior hostis"

Mark

[OH Osthaus]

so - here as in all cases (and sadly it seems all businesses)

Caveat emptor


in the end - its your money, spend wisely

[Bill Murphy]

Yup, Rich. Good dealers sell bad guns and bad dealers sell good guns. You are the inspector. I will deal with almost anyone who occasionally has a good gun.