The A-1 Special 20 Gauge at Julia's 4-11-17

[edgarspencer]

Originally Posted by Craig Larter

All the prices seemed strong to me. Good for the seller and the new owner.

Not in my opinion Craig. In the English guns, only exceptional guns of best makers made the low estimate. The Rough Rider Colt would have been above the mid 20s a few years ago, and only brought 10K. It was in fine condition also. Winchester's own 8 bore test gun, a fine W&C Scott with Jones under lever, failed to sell, only barely hitting $5k. When was the last time you saw a Deluxe, Special Order 1894 sell for $2500? A 80-90% 1895 for under 1000 dollars? Pathetic.
I think the Second Chance list is going to be extensive.

[edgarspencer]

The same consecutive pair of GHEs was listed two years ago with an estimate of $17,500-$22,500. They were again listed in Yesterday's sale with an estimate of $6,000 to $10,000. The hammer fell at $5000. If they actually did sell two years ago, the consignor yesterday must be very disappointed.