I think with a proper description of what the forum is and what it isn't, it could work. Start with a few words of warning as to what people can expect when they post their gun (in other words, expect an honest answer and be prepared not to agree with everyone) and it should be fine. As for the pictures, I wouldn't worry about people being "tricky", I'd worry about people knowing the front of the camera from the back. Good clear, bright pictures will be critical. Afterall, if they want to get tricky with the photos, they are only hurting themselves. I think to avoid a lot of unnecessary back and forth, there should be some minimum required shots of specific areas of the gun in order for everyone to make a good assessment.
Mike
|