After doing a fair amount of reading on various forums there does not seem to be a clear cut solution to the problem.  The mix of comments is about 50/50 but of those that have had good luck with a baffle, they seem to prefer the red plastic.  Maybe because they are less expensive. 
 
I have done a little experimenting.  Probably spent too much time researching.  I installed a metal baffle and to my surprise the powder charge dropped changed significantly, >1 grain.  Interestingly, the change was an increase in dropped powder charge with the baffle installed.  Just the opposite of what I would guess. 
 
A friend of mine who is an ardent baffle user decided to try some E3 powder for one of his loads.  The results were extremely erratic with a red baffle installed with dropped charges varying by as much as 3 grains.  He was baffled!
		 
		
		
		
		
		
		
		
	 |