Parker Gun Collectors Association Forums

Parker Gun Collectors Association Forums (https://parkerguns.org/forums/index.php)
-   Shotgun Shell Reloading (https://parkerguns.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=21)
-   -   2 7/8" 10ga Reloading Data (https://parkerguns.org/forums/showthread.php?t=6282)

Mark Ouellette 11-18-2014 05:08 AM

Do not use Hevi Shot instead of another type of non-toxic listed in the loading data. The hardness of the shot affects pressure. In general the harder the shot the higher the peak pressure. Hevi Shot is harder than most other non-toxic shot types.

Bill Murphy 11-18-2014 08:57 AM

Pete, (and others) the published loads with 44 or 45 grains of Herco don't sound right because they are ridiculous loads, not because of a misprint or a change in the character of the powder over the years. The velocity of those loads is 1350 and up. No one needs such a load, either in a fluid steel gun or a Damascus gun. Pete, thanks for publishing the spreadsheet, but maybe we shouldn't include every published load, certainly not the ones mentioned.

Pete Lester 11-21-2014 08:11 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Murphy (Post 151388)
Pete, (and others) the published loads with 44 or 45 grains of Herco don't sound right because they are ridiculous loads, not because of a misprint or a change in the character of the powder over the years. The velocity of those loads is 1350 and up. No one needs such a load, either in a fluid steel gun or a Damascus gun. Pete, thanks for publishing the spreadsheet, but maybe we shouldn't include every published load, certainly not the ones mentioned.

Bill, I agree you with you that I would not use that much Herco and shoot it in any gun. As far as the spreadsheet goes my goal was to find and record in a single place all published loads for the 2 7/8" 10 gauge. As you can see from the attached scan these loads were published in the 1968 Hercules "Smokeless Powder Guide". The benefit here is that if these loads were published then they would have been within SAAMI standards for pressure at the time, which does not mean they are suitable for composite barrels. Although some of the components are no longer available it allows reloaders who wildcat to make better educated decisions about their reloads. I agree 44/45 grains of Herco is too much, but a 25% reduction to 32/33 grains may be a nice load, and that is the value of the spreadsheet as I see it.

Rick Losey 11-21-2014 08:18 AM

Peter - those of us who came late to the short 10 really appreciate all of your effort

looking at these loads- i find it odd they do not specify a brand for the hull or primer - both components that have an affect on pressure.

Pete Lester 11-21-2014 08:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rick Losey (Post 151605)
Peter - those of us who came late to the short 10 really appreciate all of your effort

looking at these loads- i find it odd they do not specify a brand for the hull or primer - both components that have an affect on pressure.

Thanks, it is odd by today's standards but that information, hull, primer and pressure is not to be found in that 1968 Hercules publication.

Steve Havener 11-26-2014 01:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shane johnson (Post 69622)
Great stuff, if only you had some for 2 5/8".....:(

Shane if you roll crimp you may be able to use the 2 7/8th inch folded crimp data for your 2 5/8th inch loads. I use fiber wads in my 10 gauge loads so adjusting wad column height by 1/4 inch is not a problem

Rick Losey 11-26-2014 07:13 PM

i have been roll crimping all my 2 5/8 - and so far have not tried a low pressure load from Peter's sheet that I could not use.

Mark Garrett 01-23-2015 11:09 AM

Need a little help .Not very familiar with 10Ga loadings , but being that I just bought an Ithaca Super 10ga I need to start . What Remington hulls is being referred to in the spread sheet with these designations , Rem whtltr , Rem OS, Rem blkltr . Can all the Remington hulls with a plastic base wad be used interchangeably ?

Thanks.

Pete Lester 01-23-2015 11:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Garrett (Post 156832)
Need a little help .Not very familiar with 10Ga loadings , but being that I just bought an Ithaca Super 10ga I need to start . What Remington hulls is being referred to in the spread sheet with these designations , Rem whtltr , Rem OS, Rem blkltr . Can all the Remington hulls with a plastic base wad be used interchangeably ?

Thanks.

Congrats on the new gun. Rem Hulls white letter is as the name applies, they are factory loaded hulls stamped with white letter marking. I have a bunch that were factory busmuth loads. Rem black letter, same thing, black letter stamping, I have seen that on what were factory steel shot loads. Rem OS, I am not sure what OS stands for. I purchased some unfired Rem hulls with no markings for a snow goose hunt a couple of years ago and loaded them with SR7625 and Bismuth 1's. I shot them through a Twist barrel Parker NH and Rem 1894 Damascus gun without issue. If the Remington hulls have a plastic base wad I load them the same but that's just me.

Mark Garrett 01-23-2015 12:04 PM

Thanks for help the help . I bought some new Remington hulls from Precision , so they should work just fine . I have 700x on hand and will load some 1 1/8 loads and try her out . I also have a fair amount of 7625 on but am saving that for my 16ga LP hunting Loads .

I plan on putting some Bismuth loads together for the short 10 , but don't really need or want low pressure , so I will develope something with another powder and send them to Tom Armburst for testing .

Thanks again for the Explanation .

Mark

Pete Lester 07-18-2015 01:24 PM

1 Attachment(s)
It has been awhile since I have seen any new data but thanks to Mark Garrett and Craig Larter we have three new loadings, two of them for Bismuth, for the Short Ten. Remember many of these loads use obsolete components and data that is several decades old. I suggest you verify the data when possible and as always remember you proceed at your own risk.

Frederick Getman 07-21-2015 12:06 AM

10 ga. 2 7/8" laoding data
 
Hello
Where can I find and download your data on 10ga. reloading?

Thank You

Frederick






Quote:

Originally Posted by Pete Lester (Post 61528)
Attached is a PDF copy of the spreadsheet for loads I have been able to find so far for the short ten. The loads are exclusive of the Sherman Bell data many of us our familiar with. Please note I have given credit to the person who started the spreadsheet and shared it with me as well as citing the source of the information, some of it from the 1960's. Not all components are available today but I think the data is interesting and useful. It is obvious a variety of Alliant and IMR powders will work in the short ten. I thought it was interesting Hercules (forerunner to Alliant) did not bother to list hull type or primer type nor chamber pressure in the 1968 guide. You will need to zoom this to 200% to read it easily, I had to shrink it to keep my format in tact.

If you run across any other published loads please let me know about them and I will update this. Enjoy.


Rick Losey 07-21-2015 08:36 AM

Frederick

There is a PDF attached to Peter's post

That is the load data

Pete Lester 07-21-2015 09:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rick Losey (Post 173037)
Frederick

There is a PDF attached to Peter's post

That is the load data


Make that, attached to my most recent post. I deleted the previous versions of the spreadsheet and uploaded the most recent addition with the new loadings in my post here of 7/18/15 at 1:24PM.

Frederick Getman 07-21-2015 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pete Lester (Post 173045)
Make that, attached to my most recent post. I deleted the previous versions of the spreadsheet and uploaded the most recent addition with the new loadings in my post here of 7/18/15 at 1:24PM.

Hello Rick
Thank You for the response.

I guess I am brain dead. I don't know how to get to the file and then see it to download it. Would you assist a grayed haired old man in this regard?

Thank You

Frederick

Rick Losey 07-21-2015 10:51 AM

Are you on a windows PC?
Assuming you have a PDF reader (if not ADOBE READER is a free download at adobe.com )

Just click on the attachment and it will offer you a choice to read or save

Pick the save option and a copy will be stored on your computer in the downloads folder

Frederick Getman 07-21-2015 12:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rick Losey (Post 173050)
Are you on a windows PC?
Assuming you have a PDF reader (if not ADOBE READER is a free download at adobe.com )

Just click on the attachment and it will offer you a choice to read or save

Pick the save option and a copy will be stored on your computer in the downloads folder

Hello OH

Wow. This is the first time I saw the file on the post. Wonder why it wasn't showing up before? Yes I have downloaded it. Super. Thanks for the help. I will need to enlarge it somehow.

Thanks Again

Primerbuster Here.

Scott Gentry 09-02-2015 11:05 PM

Bismuth
 
Just got some Bismuth for short 10 waterfowl loads, shot is more like fine gravel than typical round shot. Several sizes and shapes, mostly tear drop shapes.
Anyone have this experience with Bismuth?

Frederick Getman 09-03-2015 01:12 AM

Bismuth
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scott Gentry (Post 176308)
Just got some Bismuth for short 10 waterfowl loads, shot is more like fine gravel than typical round shot. Several sizes and shapes, mostly tear drop shapes.
Anyone have this experience with Bismuth?

Hello Scott
Yes Bismuth shot doesn't look very symmetrical, but boy does it shoot well and throws a dense pattern. It penetrates much better than steel as it is more dense!

Hope this helps!

Primerbuster

CraigThompson 09-03-2015 01:26 PM

FWIW , a couple months ago I found out that Ponsness Warren WILL make a new LS-1000 10 gauge 3 1/2" machine into a 2 7/8" machine for the measly extra cost of $30 !

John Muddiman 09-15-2015 03:39 PM

2/78 10 reloading
 
i would like to SAY A BIG THANK YOU for the loads i have been trying everywhere to find some i have tried other forums with no luck . i would like to thank the administrator who sorted out my login in problems for me once again THANK YOU ALL for the help i received as in the UK we have hardly any data at all and have to rely on you chaps over in the US for help cheers

Rick Losey 09-15-2015 04:27 PM

You are of course welcome

A grand thanks would be some photos of your days on the foreshore and the grey lags or pinkfeet geese taken with your new found knowledge.

Good shooting to you

William Davis 09-16-2015 04:48 AM

1 1/8 oz 7 1/2. Remington SP 10 wad half inch 16 g fiber wad inside the SP 10. Either 19 Red Dot or 22 Green Dot is my standard Clay Target short 10 load. Unique being slower powder perhaps a grain or two more. Split the fiber wad to make the stack come out right for fold crimping.

Hunting, depending on the bird, I think I will go 1 1/4 oz and a very small increase in the Green Dot charge. Am ordering a bag of # 7 shot and working up loads to to use on Crows. 7 and 1 1/4 exceeds limits at most Clay target clubs, and lot more than needed for targets.

William

Robert Watts 11-18-2015 04:41 PM

Got it, are most of the lighter loads for the 2 7/8 hull length?

scott kittredge 11-18-2015 05:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Robert Watts (Post 181988)
Got it, are most of the lighter loads for the 2 7/8 hull length?

all the loads here are for the 2 7/8 ths inch shells

Robert Watts 11-19-2015 10:48 AM

I saw that after I enlarged the print on the copier, but thank you. I cranked out my first bp load for the short 10 last nite. One of Sherman Bell's. My gun isn't a Parker but an Ithaca Flues model with Damascus barrels and the 6000 range of pressure is sure what I was looking for. RW

Pete Lester 11-19-2015 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by William Davis (Post 177246)
1 1/8 oz 7 1/2. Remington SP 10 wad half inch 16 g fiber wad inside the SP 10. Either 19 Red Dot or 22 Green Dot is my standard Clay Target short 10 load. Unique being slower powder perhaps a grain or two more. Split the fiber wad to make the stack come out right for fold crimping.

Hunting, depending on the bird, I think I will go 1 1/4 oz and a very small increase in the Green Dot charge. Am ordering a bag of # 7 shot and working up loads to to use on Crows. 7 and 1 1/4 exceeds limits at most Clay target clubs, and lot more than needed for targets.

William

Scott and I shoot a lot of crows, hundreds for each of us each fall. We have tried shot sizes from 4's to 8's over the years. If you want the most effective shell for a crow at any range your shotgun can shoot go with #6 in any trap or skeet loading. You will see a noticable difference. Far more dead in the air folds over the smaller shot including #7.

William Davis 11-20-2015 04:23 PM

Pete

No doubt about it # 6 will kill at distance. When I hunted Ducks with Lead # 6 was all I used. Problem with the 6's for me is shooting light shot loads in SxS's I don't think I get enough pellets. Look at it this way, all from internet charts. nothing actually counted

For my 12 g loads

1 oz load # 7 296 pellets
1 oz load # 6 222 pellets

For my 10 G loads

1 1/8 oz # 7 331 pellets
1 1/8 oz # 6 308 pellets

Of course I could bump the 12's to 1 1/8 and 10's to 1 1/4. I have some RST 1 1/4 # 6 and they recoil too much in my 9 1/4 lb Ithaca Super 10. Not so bad in my 10 lb Parker Hammer 10. Never liked Factory 1 1/8 oz in 12 G Parkers either.

Good thing about loading is you can get it exactly like you want it.

William

Pete Lester 11-20-2015 04:58 PM

2 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by William Davis (Post 182061)
Pete

No doubt about it # 6 will kill at distance. When I hunted Ducks with Lead # 6 was all I used. Problem with the 6's for me is shooting light shot loads in SxS's I don't think I get enough pellets. Look at it this way, all from internet charts. nothing actually counted

For my 12 g loads

1 oz load # 7 296 pellets
1 oz load # 6 222 pellets

For my 10 G loads

1 1/8 oz # 7 331 pellets
1 1/8 oz # 6 308 pellets

Of course I could bump the 12's to 1 1/8 and 10's to 1 1/4. I have some RST 1 1/4 # 6 and they recoil too much in my 9 1/4 lb Ithaca Super 10. Not so bad in my 10 lb Parker Hammer 10. Never liked Factory 1 1/8 oz in 12 G Parkers either.

Good thing about loading is you can get it exactly like you want it.

William

Not to pick on you William but I always find it humorous when a fellow crow hunter worries about pattern density when using #6. Trust me they will dump them consistently at any range you dare to shoot, even with open chokes. With tight chokes they are never getting though it.

Here are patterns through a Remington 10ga 1894 and 12ga 1900, these are both 1 1/8 ounce loads at 40 yards. The 12ga has a mere .024 of choke. Scott has a picture somewhere of a 7/8 ounce pattern of #6 on the life size vitals of a crow at 40 yards. If centered the bird would not survived.

PS. Your pellet counts are off, at least for #6. Most charts cite 225 per ounce. My hand count for pattern test below was 253 for 1 1/8 ounce.

scott kittredge 11-20-2015 06:07 PM

[QUOTE=William Davis;182061]Pete
Problem with the 6's for me is shooting light shot loads in SxS's I don't think I get enough pellets.
I have shot 100's of crows over the years with 7/8th oz of 6's out on my 20 ga. For years that's all i shot when crow hunting. so i am sure i have shot 2000 crow with that load alone. There are plenty of pellets in 1 oz of 6's out of the 10 or 12 ga. i have killed close to 500 this year alone with above loads, for one shot size stay with 6's ! check out some of Pete and my parker hunting pics under my profile It will show some of our crow hunting trips:)
what ever you shoot at crows , have fun and good luck!!:)

charlie cleveland 11-20-2015 06:32 PM

boy i gota lot of crow hunting to catch up with you boys....both of them guns are really throwing a close pattern looks to be both guns shooting 90 to 95 percent at 40 yards...charlie

Pete Lester 11-20-2015 06:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by charlie cleveland (Post 182067)
boy i gota lot of crow hunting to catch up with you boys....both of them guns are really throwing a close pattern looks to be both guns shooting 90 to 95 percent at 40 yards...charlie

Well that is something to look forward to! Looking at what I wrote in the pictures the 10 threw 92.49% and the 12 shot 88%.

William Davis 11-22-2015 09:17 AM

You have some very good patterns for sure. And there is no substitute for projectile weight. Have been shooting cast bullet rifles for years. Ballistic charts rank velocity high. On game or steel silhouette targets weight is what does the job.

I have a supply or RST 10 G 1 1-4 oz # 6. My hand loads so far for the short ten are target, 1 1-8 # 7 1-2 Looking for something between the two, with lower recoil. Both of my 10s are choked tight enough to handle # 6 either 1 1-8 or 1 1-4

12 G 1 oz another story, my guns 7 is as large as I plan to go, based on # 7 patterns so far. Am going to use the 1oz 7 for long clays mostly . Density is a issue.

Real question for me is do I buy a bag of 6 just for the short 10 hunting loads Am going to pattern some # 7 1 1-8 and see how they look.

Willam

scott kittredge 11-22-2015 05:43 PM

12 G 1 oz another story, my guns 7 is as large as I plan to go, based on # 7 patterns so far. Am going to use the 1oz 7 for long clays mostly . Density is a issue.


You might want to check, but most clay coarse have a no bigger than 7 1/2 shot rule and most "shoots" have that rule too. i would just buy the 6's and you be happy you did for crow hunting and 7 1/2 's for long ranges clays .:) scott
Willam[/QUOTE]

Pete Lester 11-22-2015 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by William Davis (Post 182133)
Real question for me is do I buy a bag of 6 just for the short 10 hunting loads Am going to pattern some # 7 1 1-8 and see how they look.

Willam

So you are questioning whether or not to spend + or - $45 for a bag of shot that would be far and away more effective for crow shooting based on what a couple of guys who have shot thousands of crows told you?

The 7's I am sure will pattern fine, but regardless of how they pattern they do not measure up to the performance of #6 on crows. Constant use of 7 will result in more visibly hit birds flying off, birds coming down screaming like they were stung by 100 bees, more walking wounded that have to be run down and dispatched. All these happens with #6 but to a much lesser extent than with #7, #7.5 and #8.

William Davis 11-22-2015 06:56 PM

Not doubting your experience, just going to see for myself. Have factory 1 1-4 oz # 6 to compare.

William

Paul Wallpe 07-17-2016 01:25 PM

Spreadsheet in Excel?
 
Does anyone have this list in the original Excel format?

Stephen Hastie 07-20-2016 03:25 PM

Hi guys I cannot find any attachments is this because I am using an iPad?

Stephen Hastie 07-21-2016 03:13 AM

Oops got it, dooh

Carvel Whaley 07-21-2016 12:38 PM

After 2or3 reloadings the Federal and Cheddit hulls I have been using start to split in the crimp. So, I tried trimming the hulls to 2 3/8 inches, use the same shot and powder load as with the 2 7/8 inch and trim the wad 1/4 inch with sizzors and don't use the 1/2 inch filler wad in the shot cup. Raise the short adapter on the MEC 600 jr up another 1/2 inch and it crimps perfect. Tried them on the crony and patterning board and see no difference. Loaded it is a neet looking 2 inch shell and you get 2 or 3 more loadings out of the hull and don't have to buy or use filler wads. Carvel


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:35 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1998 - 2025, Parkerguns.org