MULLERED CHECKERING BORDER ON A REPRO

[Bob Jurewicz]

Here is my question: How does adding a Mullered Border to a Parker Reproduction impact value ?
Bob Jurewicz

[Brett Hoop]

It’s an interesting question that could go either direction based on personal taste or how strict one’s leanings are toward original Reproduction form.

An example 28ga sold earlier this year that had mullard boarders, actual cased metal, and an oil finish, the ejector stop plate had been fixed, it brought about $4400. Now all those things shouldn’t take away from it in my view. I see them as improvements, and in truth I can’t recall why I didn’t buy it.

Those are things, I like better about Meriden Parkers. And granted an original DHE 28ga with any condition in any original barrel length is going to cost roughly 3 times +++ what a Reproduction at today’s numbers.

Somewhere here we have a thread Brian showed what can be done with a Repro. You may like the photos, but I reviewed the gun last August when he had it at Mike’s. It’s wonderful!
In my eyes because he did everything to it to make it look like a Meriden produced gun stem to stern. And that’s what I like in a Parker.

[Dean Romig]

IMO, mullering the borders a la Parker Brothers isn't necessarily correct. Tom Skuese sent several of his Remington era Parkers to Japan to be duplicated. Those guns did not have mullered borders as was done by Parker Brothers. But neither did the checkerers in Japan correctly replicate the borders in the Remington style either.

Here is what Remington borders should look like. Pictures 1, 2, 3, and 4 are Remington style borders while the last two are Parker Bros. mullered borders just for comparison. Personally I like the mullered borders but they're not correct for the Parker Reproductions by Winchester.


.

[B. Dudley]

I personally do not think that many would care. But I am sure some would.
Personally, I feel that the quality of the checkering on DHE repros is one of their poorest executed features. Anything that can be done to improve it some is not really a bad thing.

[Wild Skies]

I can't see how adding mullered borders could possibly add any value in the longterm. In fact, I believe it will prove detrimental to value to those that chose to collect Parker Reproductions. Serious collectors demand originality, adding mullered borders to a Parker Reproduction ain't original.

[Dean Romig]

But still, it’s a matter of personal preference.





.

[winplumber]

Originally Posted by Greg Baehman

I can't see how adding mullered borders could possibly add any value in the longterm. In fact, I believe it will prove detrimental to value to those that chose to collect Parker Reproductions. Serious collectors demand originality, adding mullered borders to a Parker Reproduction ain't original.

I just cant see why a reproduction is collectible . Just me I guess

[Wild Skies]

Originally Posted by Steve Huffman

I just cant see why a reproduction is collectible . Just me I guess

Just because YOU don't understand how something can be considered collectible, doesn't mean they don't exist. There are all kinds of collectors in this big wide world we live in. There are collectors of women's panties found on clotheslines, there are collectors of Japanese swords, there are collectors of Parker Bros. guns and yes, there are collectors of Parker Reproductions -- lot's of them...and likely more in the years and decades yet to come.

[Dean Romig]

The men and in women in Meriden and Ilion who created the originals probably never dreamed that in 100 or more years their utilitarian creations, no matter how plain or how ornate, would be prized so highly by collectors, nor did they have the slightest inkling that politicians of the future would like to take them away from the American public.





.

[chris dawe]

Originally Posted by Brian Dudley

I personally do not think that many would care. But I am sure some would.
Personally, I feel that the quality of the checkering on DHE repros is one of their poorest executed features. Anything that can be done to improve it some is not really a bad thing.

You can say that again it's bloody pitiful !